Comments on: Criticism of The Culture of Critique /2011/04/05/criticism-of-the-culture-of-critique/ Politics + Technology = Nonsense at the Speed of Light Tue, 01 Sep 2026 03:05:10 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.0.22 By: Udolpho.com /2011/04/05/criticism-of-the-culture-of-critique/#comment-5045 Thu, 07 Apr 2011 20:16:22 +0000 /2011/04/05/criticism-of-the-culture-of-critique/#comment-5045 I don’t feel very strongly about that criticism any more. In part this is because I doubt that groups like blacks, with significantly lower mean IQs, can really be assimilated into the kind of complex society that whites prefer. So some form of ethnic clustering is inevitably and we already do it naturally in a haphazard way.

In the original criticism I was thinking of very self-conscious white separatism, which I doubt will ever amount to anything other than small collectives of malcontents.

If anything my view now is that we should nullify obstacles to these natural ethnic clusters (affirmative action, quotas, diversity propaganda), rather than pursue out-and-out separatism.

]]> By: Tanstaafl /2011/04/05/criticism-of-the-culture-of-critique/#comment-5035 Wed, 06 Apr 2011 07:22:26 +0000 /2011/04/05/criticism-of-the-culture-of-critique/#comment-5035 “I do not agree with MacDonald that ethnic separatism offers European-derived culture anything more than devolution. I think ethnic separatism within a diverse nation will alter what we think of as Western culture and turn it into something no better than the self-interested ethnic enclaves that have exploited it. Universalism is simply a hallmark of the West; if it loses this trait, it loses itself.

The question of what to do is far too complicated to explore briefly, but a return to assimilationism and a renewal of Western values must be the only plausible course. All of our politics should be subordinate to this issue.“

PLEASUREMAN has many mainly intelligent, insightful things to say about CoC and jewish traits. But with this bit I completely disagree.

Universalism undoes those who embrace it. It loses itself. Assimilationism is precisely how self-interested ethnics exploit and displace universalists. Separatism is the only plausible course to retain any traits or hallmarks.

]]>