Comments on: Roth and Weiss on What’s Best for The Jews /2011/12/29/roth-and-weiss-on-whats-best-for-the-jews/ Politics + Technology = Nonsense at the Speed of Light Tue, 01 Sep 2026 03:05:10 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.0.22 By: Tanstaafl /2011/12/29/roth-and-weiss-on-whats-best-for-the-jews/#comment-7305 Wed, 07 Mar 2012 14:21:39 +0000 /2011/12/29/roth-and-weiss-on-whats-best-for-the-jews/#comment-7305 “Selective reading, like selective breeding, spreads all kinds of weakness, disease and foolishness.“

The thrust of your argument is that I’m stupid or crazy – specifically because I didn’t read Roth’s entire book. Did you read every post on my blog before writing that?

The other point you make is that Roth is critical of jews, or zionists at least. It seems you didn’t even read this blog post, because the point I made in it is that the basis for Roth’s criticism is what’s good for the jews. Would that Anglo Saxons, or Whites in general, torture themselves with criticism like that!

Your misreading of my critique as being all about Roth is itself selective. The “what’s good for the jews” attitude is typical of jews, not just of Roth. It is probably why his books have been so popular with jews and why he is celebrated by them rather than shunned.

Finally, I can’t help but wonder what unspoken circumstances motivate someone who purports to be an Anglo Saxon to take the time to respond to a pseudononymous critique of jewish behavior. If my opinion is so foolish then why must you even waste your time addressing it?

]]> By: Anonymous /2011/12/29/roth-and-weiss-on-whats-best-for-the-jews/#comment-7304 Wed, 07 Mar 2012 05:27:39 +0000 /2011/12/29/roth-and-weiss-on-whats-best-for-the-jews/#comment-7304 “All comments must be approved by the blog author”
So, I will begin by acknowledging the censorship of opinion exercised by the author of this blog, and (like him) I will opt to remain anonymous.
I am currently reading Roth’s “Operation Shylock” – an enterprise I would commend to the author of this blog.
As for my credentials, they don’t get much more Anglo-Saxon than mine. How many who see themselves as being supremely ‘white’ can trace their ancestry back a thousand years and more?
Having said that, the Age of Treason would be given a failing grade by anyone who has actually taken the time to read the book in question.
For the record, Roth’s book heaps more scorn on Jews than on Gentiles. Yes, those who have only referenced extracts might delight in thinking otherwise, but more the fool them.
Shakespeare’s Shylock was confounded in attempting to exact his pound of flesh, and the Age of Treason’s mischaracterization of the book’s plot betrays a similarly flawed goal. It is the epitome of either deceit or stupidity to attempt to represent this book as “jewish(sic) hostility toward Christianity, Christians, and Whites in general.”
Philip Roth does not hide his opinions behind anonymity. In “Operation Shylock”, he has run riot with the multifold failings of Jews and Zionists alike.
But, I suppose, it is simpler to take passages of the book out of context and expound on their meaning. It’s the very way too many so-called Christians demean the Bible.
And not to put too fine a turn on things, but wasn’t it a Jew named Saul who promoted the message of a Jew named Jesus so that Gentiles could also embrace the Covenant God made with mankind?
Selective reading, like selective breeding, spreads all kinds of weakness, disease and foolishness.

]]> By: Anonymous /2011/12/29/roth-and-weiss-on-whats-best-for-the-jews/#comment-7146 Mon, 13 Feb 2012 02:01:10 +0000 /2011/12/29/roth-and-weiss-on-whats-best-for-the-jews/#comment-7146 Majorityrights post relating to German economic policy here.

]]> By: Anonymous /2011/12/29/roth-and-weiss-on-whats-best-for-the-jews/#comment-7027 Wed, 01 Feb 2012 05:54:56 +0000 /2011/12/29/roth-and-weiss-on-whats-best-for-the-jews/#comment-7027 Sorry to be so late on this one; you can read P. Roth’s “Operation Shylock” here.

]]> By: Pat Hannagan /2011/12/29/roth-and-weiss-on-whats-best-for-the-jews/#comment-6828 Wed, 18 Jan 2012 06:26:27 +0000 /2011/12/29/roth-and-weiss-on-whats-best-for-the-jews/#comment-6828 Yes, thanks for that as well Zx.

Re: Im having to unlearn a lifetime of anti-Nazi propaganda.

That should be the goal of all WN sites.

]]>